Sunday, December 12, 2010

Then Sings My Soul: update


Then Sings My Soul by Robert Morgan, claims to be compiled of 150 hymns and stories about their authors and origins. However, I feel that to say that is what it is would be a lie. It is a compliment of 150 songs and their stories, but they are not all hymns, or Christian Hymns. Wikipedia defines a hymn as "a type of song, usually religious, specifically written for the purpose of praise, adoration or prayer, and typically addressed to a deity or deities, or to a prominent figure or personification..." America, the Beautiful is not praising a prominent figure or personified anything.. America is a country.

I most certainly would not recommend this book to anyone who was not an American with the inclusion of the patriotic songs, and I was kind of put off by the inclusion of "Good King Wenceslas". I would classify that as a catholic hymn as it is praising a Saint, not God. Other than that I loved learning some of the fun facts that go behind the songs. I didn't care too much for the layout or presentation of this book. I didn't understand the point of putting flaps like you would have on a hardback book's book cover on a paper back book...? And I thought the edging of the pages was too sharp and very inconsistent as they only did it on the one side and not the top or bottom. It made it very hard to flip to a page that I was looking for...

Disclosure of Material Connection: received this book free from the publisher through the book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
I review for BookSneeze

Worldview: Biblical
Target Audience: American Catholics?
Positive Elements: Really great historical facts. I also love that the sheet music and lyrics for the songs were included.
Inappropriate Language: None
Unbiblical Content: We are supposed to praise the Creator, not creation, and while I am an American, some patriotic songs just rub me the wrong way. Weren't the early Christians martyred because they refused to praise their country or king instead of God? Why must we do exactly what they were killed for not doing?
Other Negative Elements: Just the inclusion of the songs that were not Christian hymns.


  1. haha I loved the way the pages were edgy! :)

  2. Yeah, I decided the weird flappy things made pretty decent book marks and am marking two of my favorite songs :) One of them I can play on the piano (in a much more simple version) but never knew the last few verses.